IEEE HomeSearch IEEE ShopWeb Account Contact IEEE IEEE
MembershipPublicationsServicesStandardsConferencesCareers/Jobs
IEEE-SA IEEE-SA Member Area Search our standards database for Abstract, Sponsor, Status, Contact,Ordering and Historical information. IEEE-SA Standards Association
   Text Size: Small Text Normal Text Larger Text
Products & ServicesIEEE-SA MembershipStandards DevelopmentNews & InformationnavFillerHOMEHOME Icon

 

Frequently Asked Questions: Recirculating a Standard


When is a recirculation ballot necessary?

To whom does a recirculation ballot get distributed?

How can a balloter change his/her vote from negative to affirmative, or from affirmative to negative?

After the recirculation, the results still showed negative votes. What constitutes a new negative?

When must the Sponsor initiate an additional recirculation?

What if I have additional questions about balloting?


When is a recirculation ballot necessary?

A recirculation ballot is necessary when

  • There are unresolved negative comments on the original ballot, or
  • Any technical or substantive changes have been made to the draft.

 

See 5.4.3.2 of the IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual.


To whom does a recirculation ballot get distributed?

When a recirculation ballot is opened, the entire balloting group has the opportunity to review the comments, responses and the changed portions of the document.


How can a balloter change his/her vote from negative to affirmative, or from affirmative to negative?

While the ballot period is open, balloters can change their votes from negative to affirmative or vice versa through the myBallot system.

For closed ballots, balloters can change their votes from negative to affirmative or vice versa during a recirculation by waiting until the recirculation ballot opens. In the absence of a recirculation ballot, the balloter can send an email to the Sponsor advising that his/her vote has changed. The Sponsor will then submit a copy of the email to RevCom as part of the submittal package.


After the recirculation, the results still showed negative votes. What constitutes a new negative?

It is up to the ballot resolution committee of the working group to decide whether or not a negative comment is new or an iteration of a previous comment. Remember: during a recirculation ballot, balloters can only vote on the changed portion of the document and on any unresolved negative comments.


When must the Sponsor initiate an additional recirculation?

If new negatives with comments are received on changes to the draft being recirculated, or if technical changes were made to the draft as a result of the previous recirculation, the Sponsor must initiate an additional recirculation (see IEEE Standards Board Operations Manual, part 5.4.3.2).


What if I have additional questions about balloting?

For further information, go to Standards Development Online, or send an email to the IEEE-SA Balloting Center.

 
spacer
Copyright ©2005 IEEE-SA
Contact IEEE-SA
(p.stanton@ieee.org)
URL:http://standards.ieee.org/faqs/ballot.html
spacer